DID JESUS GO AGAINST THE LAW?
DID JESUS GO AGAINST THE LAW?
A lesson delivered at the Church of Christ, Ologuneru, Ibadan, Nigeria, on November 15, 2026.
Introduction:
The question before us is one of utmost importance and that has strongly divided different schools of thought.
Some believe that Jesus committed no sin and did not go against the law.
Some believe that because He is God, He had the authority to determine what to do under the law.
Some believe He rebelled against the law.
We must not approach this subject lightly because the Bible tells us Jesus committed no sin (Hebrews 4:15; 1 Peter 2:22) yet we see Jesus seeming to do things that go against the law (John 5:18).
Now, we either try to sort out these contradictions or accept they are contradictory.
Before we move on, I want us to ponder the fact that Jesus' critics could not find a word against Him (Matthew 26:59-60; John 8:46).
Firstly: Let Us Identify the Problem
Sin is defined as the transgression of the law (1 John 3:4). In simple terms, sin is going against the law. If Jesus went beyond or below the law, it means He sinned. At the time of Jesus, the law of Moses was still the rule (Galatians 4:4). Since Jesus became flesh to be able to be tempted as man, that He could bear with man, then He must be bound by every principle binding man as regards obedience to the law (Hebrews 2:14-17; 4:15). Which means He must not go against the law with the excuse that He is God. The Bible says the laws of God are not hard (1 John 5:3) and that God is faithful and reveres His words (Psalm 138:2; Hebrews 6:18). This implies that even if Jesus was not bound by all principles binding man, He must be bound by His own laws for Him to be faithful. Thus, He said, regarding His baptism, that it was to fulfil all righteousness (Matthew 3:15), which makes Him a part of those who obeyed the will of God through baptism (Luke 7:30). A mere reading of the Bible makes it seem as though Jesus did some things contrary to the law and also stated things that seem to contradict the law. We should know that for Jesus to be a perfect sacrifice, He must be a perfect man (Hebrews 5:8-9; 1 Peter 1:19). If Jesus sinned, He cannot be the perfect sacrifice (Hebrews 9:14; 1 Peter 1:18-19). If He went against the law because He was God, it means that God is not faithful to His own words (Hebrews 6:18; Titus 1:2).
What I have done in brief is to address the arguments that Jesus sinned and that Jesus could go against the law. I now aim to prove that Jesus did not sin against the law.
Secondly: Let Us Understand the Religious Setting of Jesus' Day
At the time of Jesus, the Israelites were using two systems of laws, apart from the Roman law—the written law and the oral law. The written law was the scriptures given through inspiration of God. The oral law was a body of interpretations and applications of the written law that had been passed down orally from generation to generation. Over time, these traditions became so numerous that they often overshadowed the written law itself. The Pharisees, for example, placed the oral law on equal footing with the written law and sometimes above it. Jesus affirmed the written law (Matthew 5:17-18). He obeyed it perfectly: He attended the feasts (John 7:10), paid the temple tax (Matthew 17:24-27), and kept the Sabbath (Luke 4:16). But Jesus strongly opposed the oral law when it contradicted or nullified the written law. He said, "Why do ye also transgress the commandment of God by your tradition?" (Matthew 15:3) and "Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition" (Mark 7:9). He called them hypocrites, saying, "In vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men" (Matthew 15:9).
Jesus was not against interpreting the law. He wanted the Jews to interpret the laws (Luke 12:57). He wanted His disciples to interpret His sayings (Matthew 13:51-52). He Himself interpreted the law and the prophets (Luke 24:27; John 5:39). However, He was against wrong interpretations (Matthew 22:29) and the placement of oral laws above the written law (Matthew 15:6-8; Mark 7:8-13).
Whenever we see Jesus accused of going against the law, we must first identify which law is in view—the written law of God or the oral traditions of the elders. If He was accused of breaking the written law, we must examine whether He actually did so. In every case, He obeyed the written law perfectly (Hebrews 4:15; 1 Peter 2:22). If He was accused of breaking the oral law, we must recognize that He often did so deliberately because the oral law contradicted the written law. He was not breaking God's law; He was breaking man's tradition and faulty interpretations.
Thirdly: Let Us Collate and Consider All the Passages That Seem to Say or Imply That Jesus Rebelled Against the Law
I will group the alleged offences into seven categories.
Sabbath violations: These are accusations that Jesus broke the Sabbath laws (e.g John 5:1-18; Mark 3:1-6; Luke 13:10-17; Luke 14:1-6; John 9:1-16; Mark 1:21-28-31; Matthew 12:1-2; Mark 2:23-28).
Cleanliness violations: These are accusations that Jesus and His disciples ate with unwashed hands, ate with unwashed dishes or associated with unclean people. (e.g Mark 2:14-17; Mark 7:1-23; Matthew 15:1-20)
Blasphemy: These are accusations that Jesus claimed divine prerogatives, such as forgiving sins or claiming equality with God. This category also includes the accusation that He threatened to destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days, which was used as false testimony against Him at His trial. It also includes the accusation of anger when He cleansed the temple, since His critics saw this as an unauthorized claim of authority over God's house. (e.g Mark 2:5-7; John 10:30-33; Mark 14:57-64; John 5:17-18; Matthew 26:59-61; John 2:13-21; Matthew 21:12-13)
Overturning of judgement: These are accusations that Jesus went against the law by forgiving those who should have been punished by the law (e.g John 8:1-11).
Friendship with evil: These are accusations that Jesus associated with tax collectors, sinners, and outcasts. The Pharisees believed that associating with sinners made one ceremonially unclean and guilty by association. (e.g Matthew 11:19; Luke 7:34; Luke 15:1-2).
Changing the law: These are accusations that Jesus altered the Law of Moses, such as in the Sermon on the Mount where He said, "Ye have heard that it was said... but I say unto you." (e.g Matthew 23:23; Matthew 5:21-48)
Treason: This category has nothing to do with the Jewish law. The Jewish leaders brought the charge of treason against Jesus to the Roman authorities because they wanted Him executed. They knew that the Romans would not execute Him for blasphemy, but they would execute Him for treason. (Luke 23:2-4; John 19:4-12; Luke 23:4-22).
This categorization is important because it shows the pattern of the accusations against Jesus. If we treat a category, we have treated all the cases under that category.
1. Sabbath Violations
The Sabbath was first mentioned when God was still sending manna (Exodus 16:22-30). It was later codified in the Ten Commandments (Exodus 20:8-11). In that command, God mentioned that the Israelites must rest on the seventh day and must do no work. He told them why (Exodus 31:12-17). He told them the least of works they must not do (Exodus 35:2-3). He explained who should rest (Deuteronomy 5:12-15). However, the definition of work was not given. Exodus 35:3 says, "Ye shall kindle no fire throughout your habitations upon the sabbath day." This could be interpreted as forbidding the lighting of any fire. However, the context of Exodus 16:23 could suggests that this was about cooking—gathering wood, building a fire, and preparing food. It does not mean that a candle could not be lit for light. The Jews were left to interpret what work meant. In Numbers 15:32-36 we see the case of a man who was found gathering sticks on the Sabbath. The people did not know what to do with him despite that the law made it clear that anyone who works on the sabbath must be killed. They had to ask God. This shows that the Jews themselves were still learning what constituted work on the Sabbath. Now, the oral tradition, through interpretations of the learned in the law, sometimes included other things to define what work is. This included the distance to walk and the weight of what to carry. Jesus understood the law. While He did not go against the law of Sabbath, He went against some of their interpretations. Jesus pointed out the faults in their interpretations.
He told them that they had wrongly defined work to mean almost anything, but work does not mean everything. He proved this by saying His Father kept working after the creation (John 5:17). God did not cease all work on the Sabbath. He continues to sustain the universe. If God continues to work on the Sabbath, then not all work is forbidden. The Sabbath command was not about ceasing from all activity.
He told them that they had failed to understand the purpose of the Sabbath. The purpose of the Sabbath was to force man to save himself by resting (Mark 2:27). Thus He mentioned the case of David, whom they agreed was right because of purpose (Matthew 12:3-4; 1 Samuel 21:1-6). The principle is that the Sabbath was made for man's benefit, not for man's harm.
He pointed out that their interpretation was biased by telling them that they would go to save a sheep on the Sabbath but forbid a man from doing the simplest of activities (Matthew 12:11-12). They would rescue a sheep that fell into a pit on the Sabbath, but they would condemn a man for being healed on the Sabbath. If it was lawful to do good to an animal on the Sabbath, how much more lawful was it to do good to a human being?
In John 5:1-18, He was accused of healing and telling a man to carry his mat. Healing was not a physical activity, and carrying a mat was like holding a staff. In Mark 3:1-6, He was accused of healing, which does not involve physical activity. The same is true with Luke 13:10-17, John 9:1-16, and Mark 1:21-31. In Matthew 12:1-2, His disciples were accused of working by plucking the ears of grain. This was not classified as work even in the law. Deuteronomy 23:24-25 explicitly permitted the poor to pluck grain from a neighbor's field. This was not considered reaping or harvesting. The disciples were not working on the Sabbath; they were eating. The Pharisees had elevated their tradition above the written law, condemning the innocent.
In every case, Jesus was accused of breaking the oral tradition, not the written law. He healed on the Sabbath, but healing is not work. He told a man to carry his mat, but carrying a mat is not work. His disciples plucked grain, but plucking grain was permitted by the law. Jesus was not a Sabbath-breaker. He was a Sabbath-keeper who challenged the traditions of men.
2. Blasphemy
The Jews, or rather the Jewish leaders of the day, accused Jesus of two things in this regard (1) claiming to be divine, and (2) disturbing the worship of God. It was a sin under the law to claim divinity or to show contempt for the name of God. Anything that affects the worship of God would be sinful. If Jesus had disrupted the worship of God, He would have committed a sin (Leviticus 19:30).
Regarding claiming to be divine, the Jewish leaders proved they did not know the Scriptures when they accused Jesus. Jesus had to use several examples to prove to them that even the law and the prophets testified to more than one person in the Godhead. He said Abraham looked forward to His day (John 8:56), making reference to the promise of God to Abraham (Genesis 12:3; 22:18). He mentioned the statements of David (Psalm 110:1; cf. Matthew 22:41-46; Mark 12:35-37; Luke 20:41-44) and the other prophets (Daniel 7:13-14; cf. Matthew 26:64; Mark 14:62; Luke 22:69; Isaiah 9:6; cf. Matthew 1:23; Luke 1:32-33) who mentioned a Lord different from the Father. He said that if they did not have a problem when the scriptures said "ye are gods" to humans (Psalm 82:6; cf. John 10:34-36), why should they have a problem if He should say so. Jesus was not blaspheming; He was making a true claim about His identity. To prove that He was completely right, He pointed to four witnesses:
First, the Scriptures: Jesus said, "Search the scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life: and they are they which testify of me" (John 5:39).
Second, John the Baptist: Jesus said, "Ye sent unto John, and he bare witness unto the truth" (John 5:33-35).
Third, His works: Jesus said, "The works which the Father hath given me to finish, the same works that I do, bear witness of me" (John 5:36).
Fourth, the Father Himself: Jesus said, "The Father himself, which hath sent me, hath borne witness of me" (John 5:37-38; 8:18). Therefore, Jesus did not commit blasphemy. If they had been able to convict Him of blasphemy, they would not have needed false witnesses against Him (Matthew 26:59-61; Mark 14:55-59).
The statement about destroying the temple was also considered blasphemous (Matthew 26:61; Mark 14:58) because it seemed to mean halting the worship of God. However, it is clear that Jesus was not referring to the physical temple but to His body (John 2:19-21). When He chased people away from the temple, the Bible did not say He chased everyone. He chased those who were turning the temple, particularly the portion where the Gentiles stayed, into a place of business (Matthew 21:12-13; Mark 11:15-17; Luke 19:45-46; John 2:14-16). Jesus was simply returning the temple to its proper order. Some people were not happy (Matthew 21:15), but it was not because He had committed any sin. The chief priests and scribes were unhappy because they saw Jesus as a threat to their authority and their lucrative temple business. They were not concerned about righteousness; they were concerned about their power and profit.
In every case, the accusation of blasphemy against Jesus was false. He did not claim to be someone He was not. He did not threaten to destroy the temple. He did not disrupt worship. He did not blaspheme when He forgave sins. Jesus Himself said the people of the day did not convict Him of sin (John 8:46).
4. Cleanliness Violations
Jesus was accused of not fasting, not washing plates and hands, and (by some today) of touching unclean people like the leper.
In Mark 7:1-23, Jesus challenged the tradition of ritual handwashing before eating. Matthew has a parallel account (Matthew 15:1-20). Mark adds a parenthetical comment: "Thus he declared all foods clean" (Mark 7:19). This is Mark's inspired commentary on the significance of Jesus' teaching. It does not mean that Jesus was breaking the dietary laws at that moment. It means that Mark, writing after the resurrection, understood that Jesus' teaching would eventually lead to the abolition of the dietary restrictions. Giving a short commentary on what Jesus meant by an action or statement was typical of the gospel writers (John 2:21-22; 12:33). At the time of Jesus, He was challenging the dishwashing traditions of the Pharisees, which were ordinances not found anywhere in the law. He made them understand that not washing dishes does not make a man sinful, as whatsoever is eaten is purged out, but that the heart of man is what determines sinfulness. The Pharisees had neglected this important part (Mark 7:14-23). He also spoke about other things the Pharisees included in the law which were not part of the law (Mark 7:8-13). To prove that Jesus obeyed the dietary laws, it took Peter time to understand the change (Acts 10:9-16). If Jesus had not been obeying the dietary laws, Peter, who had been with Him for three years, would not have issues going against the dietary laws.
In Luke 14:1-6, Jesus healed a man with dropsy at a Pharisee's house. Here, looking at the law, it seems that in addition to the Sabbath, Jesus sinned against the law of leprosy (Leviticus 13-14). But the law of leprosy was a law to protect the children of Israel against contamination (Leviticus 13:1-3). Leprosy is an uncleanness like menstruation and the ejaculation of semen (Leviticus 15). Jesus touched the leprous man before he was healed (Matthew 8:3). Instead of Jesus becoming ceremonially unclean, His touch made the leper whole. In another place, to show His adherence to the law, He commanded the one who was healed to present himself before the priest (Matthew 8:4; Luke 5:14). That other places do not mention Him making that statement does not prove that He did not obey that law. Since the leprous became healed immediately, Jesus was clean. In the case of the woman with the issue of blood that had been bleeding for twelve years (Mark 5:25), according to the law, she was ceremonially unclean (Leviticus 15:25-30). We should understand that Jesus did not initiate the contact. Even if Jesus had initiated the contact, since the woman became whole immediately, Jesus was free from uncleanness.
This interpretation applies to all places where Jesus was in contact with those who were bodily unclean.
Regarding fasting, Jesus was accused of neglect (Matthew 9:14-15; Mark 2:18-20; Luke 5:33-35). Fasting was not a general requirement of the law, except for certain times (Leviticus 16:29-31; 23:27-32). Jesus observed the feasts (Luke 2:41-42; John 7:10), and the feasts included fasting. Therefore, Jesus would have observed the required fasts. The accusation against Jesus was not about the required fasts but about the extra, routine fastings of some which Jesus said was not necessary for His disciples. The text itself says ‘the disciples of the Pharisees and John the Baptist were the ones doing the fast’, it wasn’t a requirement for all Israelites.
In every case, Jesus was accused of breaking the oral traditions of the Pharisees, not the written law of Moses. He did not break the dietary laws. He did not violate the law of leprosy. He did not neglect the required fasts. He was clean, and He made others clean. Jesus was not a lawbreaker. He was a law-keeper who challenged the traditions of men.
4. Overturning of Judgement
The case of the woman caught in adultery is often presented as a powerful argument against Jesus. It is frequently said that Jesus overrode the law by forgiving the woman. However, a careful look at the passage shows otherwise. Jesus did not go against the law; rather, He was upholding the law. The law required both parties to be executed (Leviticus 20:10; Deuteronomy 22:22), but the Jews brought only the woman (John 8:3-4), which made them guilty of sin themselves. If Jesus had agreed that the woman should be killed, He would have been going against both the law of Moses and breaking the Roman law, which did not permit the Jews to carry out capital punishment (John 18:31). If He had said the woman should go free, they would have accused Him of condoning sin. Jesus said, "He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her" (John 8:7). This was not a denial of the law. It was a challenge to the witnesses. The law required that the witnesses to a capital crime be the first to cast stones (Deuteronomy 17:7). Jesus was asking, "Are you qualified to be witnesses? Are your hands clean?" When they heard this, they were convicted by their own consciences because they didn’t bring the other party and left one by one. Moreso, Jesus wasn’t the priest who should have pronounced such capital punishment on the woman. The Bible says the purpose of the scribes and Pharisees coming to Jesus was to trap Him (John 8:6). They could not come with perfection to trap Him; they had to be faulty themselves.
Jesus was not overturning the law. He was exposing the hypocrisy of the accusers, upholding the law's requirement for witnesses, maintaining that the law required the man and the woman be judged, and extending mercy to a repentant sinner. This is not a case of Jesus breaking the law. It is a case of Jesus fulfilling the law.
5. Friendship with Evil
Matthew 11:19; Luke 7:34; 15:1-2 have also been used to prove that Jesus went against the law that required the expulsion of sinners and Jesus was also involved in wrong conducts. However, a careful look at the passage will observe that Jesus was only accused. He was accused of being a drunkard (Matthew 11:19), which was a false charge.
The sinners Jesus associated with in all cases (Luke 5:30-32; 7:37-50; 15:1-2; 19:1-10) were repentant sinners, thus His statement that He came to save the sinners (Luke 19:10).
6. Changing the Law
Jesus' statements in Matthew 5 have also been used to prove Jesus rebelled against the law in those places where He said, "You have heard but I say unto you" (Matthew 5:21-22, 27-28, 33-34, 38-39, 43-44). If Jesus altered an iota in the law before the fulfillment of the law, it means He went against the law. It was a sin to alter the law of Moses (Deuteronomy 4:2) and the law was fulfilled only at Christ's death (Colossians 2:14-15). Jesus Himself made His audience know that He was not going against the law (Matthew 5:17-18). Simply put, Jesus was only interpreting the law. There were schools of thought who interpreted the law during the time of Jesus. It was normal for one who is learned to interpret the law. In the place that says Jesus spoke as one with authority (Matthew 7:28-29), the reason why the people said He spoke as one with authority was because He was interpreting the law. Take, for example, the place where He said, "Today is the scripture fulfilled in your ears" (Luke 4:21). That was an interpretation. The Greek word translated "but" in Matthew 5 is de. It can mean "but," "and," or "now." In this context, it is not introducing a contrast that cancels the law. It is introducing an explanation that clarifies the law. Jesus was saying, "You have been told this, but this is what it means." Some argue that Jesus was changing the law because He said, "But I say unto you." But this is a misunderstanding. Jesus was not pitting His words against Moses. He was pitting His interpretation against the wrong interpretations of the day. He was saying, "You have heard this interpretation, but I say the true meaning is this." For example, in Matthew 5:21-22, the law said, "Thou shalt not kill." Jesus said, "Whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment." Jesus was not changing the law; He was showing that the law against murder begins in the heart. In Matthew 5:27-28, the law said, "Thou shalt not commit adultery." Jesus said, "Whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart." Jesus was not changing the law; He was showing that the law against adultery begins in the heart.
Matthew 23:23 has also been used to teach that Jesus was against the payment of tithes. However, even a careless reading of the passage should show that Jesus was telling the Pharisees not to neglect mercy while meticulously paying their tithes, but that they should do both. This doesn’t mean that we should pay tithes today. It means that during the time of Jesus, Jesus didn’t forbid tithings because the law of Moses was still the rule.
In every case, Jesus was interpreting the law, not changing it. He fulfilled the law by showing its true meaning. The scribes and Pharisees had obscured the law with their traditions. Jesus came to clear away the confusion and to show the law's true intent. He did not come to destroy the law but to fulfil it (Matthew 5:17).
7. Treason
Apart from the law, Jesus did not sin against the Roman government. He paid His taxes (Matthew 17:24-27; 22:15-22) and the Roman rulers found no sin in Him (Luke 23:4, 14-15, 22; John 18:38; 19:4, 6).
Conclusion
We have examined the passages that seem to suggest Jesus went against the law. In every case, a careful study reveals that Jesus was not breaking the law. He was interpreting it correctly, fulfilling it, or challenging the human traditions that had been added to it. Jesus is the perfect, sinless Son of God. He committed no sin, and no deceit was found in His mouth (1 Peter 2:22). He is the spotless Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29). He is the perfect sacrifice who can save us and who will judge the world in righteousness (Acts 17:31).
We should never forget that those in the days of Jesus could not convict Him of sin. His enemies watched Him daily, hoping to find a flaw. They questioned Him, tested Him, and spied on Him. Yet they had to resort to false witnesses at His trial because they could find no true charge against Him. If Jesus had gone against the law, false witnesses would have been unnecessary.
For we have not an high priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities; but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15).
Comments
Post a Comment